Villian in this hand is running at about 25/17. I've 3bet him several times (on multiple tables) and this is the first time he's called me.

POKERSTARS GAME #7735987525: HOLD'EM NO LIMIT ($1/$2) - 2007/01/02 - 20:51:41 (ET)
Table 'Theotes II' 6-max Seat #1 is the button
Seat 1: kimobean ($105.80 in chips)
Seat 2: metboi08 ($170.20 in chips)
Seat 5: GodlikeRoy ($236.15 in chips)
Seat 6: kchenneth ($242.85 in chips)
metboi08: posts small blind $1
GodlikeRoy: posts big blind $2

*** HOLE CARDS ***
Dealt to GodlikeRoy
kchenneth: raises $6 to $8
kimobean: folds
metboi08: folds
GodlikeRoy: raises $18 to $26
kchenneth: calls $18

*** FLOP ***
GodlikeRoy: bets $36
kchenneth: calls $36

*** TURN ***

What's my plan from here?

Push? BTP, methinks...push is too much.

I like turn ck/call. I don't think he's folding so I don't think a push gets you any FE. It just depends on your reads and if you'll felt there.